Thursday, July 31, 2008

GDP Report is Good News; Deflator Critics are Wrong

Some people (mentioned here, for example) are denigrating the GDP report, which appears to show a 1.9% rate of real growth, on the grounds that the deflator – used to convert from nominal GDP to real GDP – is artificially low because it doesn’t include imports (which have become more expensive, due primarily to changes in the price of one dark, viscous liquid that is included in their number). As far as I can tell, these people are confusing production with terms of trade. It’s true that the “average American” is worse off when the terms of trade deteriorate, but that isn’t what GDP is supposed to measure. And frankly, it’s not what I, as a macroeconomist, care about.

If it’s a really big deal to you that people who have jobs can’t (on average) buy quite as much with their paychecks as they could 3 months ago, then go ahead and criticize the GDP report (but be careful how you phrase your criticism). Personally, I care a lot more about the people that don’t have jobs, or potentially won’t have jobs in the future. The biggest reason that I care about the GDP report is that more production means more demand for labor. (I’m speaking in relative terms, of course. In absolute terms, a 1.9% growth rate is probably not enough even to keep employment stable, let alone absorb normal labor force growth – but this has nothing to do with the deflator.) Production increased by 1.9% in the second quarter. As far as the implication for labor demand, it doesn’t make a damn bit of difference what you could or couldn’t buy with that extra production.

The second big reason I care about the GDP report is what it suggests about trends in productivity. What happens in one particular quarter isn’t, in itself, of great consequence, but it does tend to make us revise our estimates of what will happen in the future. If productivity is growing quickly in the present, then we can be more confident about its future growth. I haven’t tried to do the calculations, but since employment fell significantly in the second quarter, productivity must have risen by considerably more than 1.9%, and that sounds like good news to me.

Again, the terms of trade are irrelevant, unless you think you can extrapolate changes in the terms of trade the same way we extrapolate productivity. Does the fact that oil prices rose quickly in the second quarter make you think they will rise more quickly in the future? Maybe according to some theories, but my theory is based on the observation that oil demand is much more elastic in the long run than in the short run. If prices rise in the short run, while demand is elastic in the long run, that means future demand is likely to decline and push prices down rather than up. Obviously that’s a limited view and an oversimplification, but you’re going to have to do some pretty fancy theoretical gymnastics to get the result that rates of oil price growth are persistent over long periods of time.

I think the 1.9% growth number is the right number to look at, and it’s better than I expected. Apparently, it is not quite as good as the consensus expected (2.3%, according to Briefing.com, as reported by Yahoo.)

But the other number you might want to look at is inventory investment, which (as James Hamilton points out in the article I linked in the first paragraph) was severely negative in the second quarter. Inventory investment is not something that can be extrapolated. If anything, it is more likely to correct after an unusual move because the move was often the result of a mismatch between planned production and actual sales. (For example, in the second quarter, the drop in inventories may have been the result of having better than expected sales, which would lead us to expect positive inventory investment in the third quarter.) Once you account for declining inventories, growth of final sales was probably enough to imply a positive growth trend for employment, once all the inventory and cyclical labor usage issues wash out. That sounds like good news to me.

24 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

It’s true that the “average American” is worse off... And frankly, it’s not what I, as a macroeconomist, care about.

Nice to see someone admit it.

bob mcmanus

Thu Jul 31, 10:44:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Matt Nolan said...

Very nice description of the data!

Fri Aug 01, 12:31:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Matt Nolan said...

"Nice to see someone admit it."

As a welfare economist he cares about the welfare expectations.

As a macro-economist he cares about the outlook for aggregate statistics such as GDP and unemployment.

Splitting it in this way allows him to split the positivist and normative elements of his job as an economist - this is an excellent thing to do as it makes his statements more transparent.

Hopefully that is what you mean by "nice to see someone admit it".

Fri Aug 01, 12:35:00 AM EDT  
Blogger knzn said...

I should note, though, that I am making a normative statement when I say that differences in the real income of the average American from quarter to quarter are not what I care about. The difference in having to buy a cheaper TV set in order to save money for gas, or having to take a vacation closer to home, is pretty insignificant compared to the difference between having a job and not having one. I care about productivity because these relatively small differences in income add up over time and become very large. But a one-time terms of trade shock, while it may be mildly unpleasant, is really no big deal.

Fri Aug 01, 08:57:00 AM EDT  
Blogger knzn said...

(clarifying my previous comment) A one-time terms of trade shock is no big deal except to the extent that it impacts unemployment or productivity. (I wonder if one-time shocks can impact productivity in the long run, but from looking at the 70s, it seems maybe they can.) So I'm saying, once you look at real growth, you already know the important stuff about the effects of the terms of trade shock. There's no need to further adjust for the direct effect of terms of trade on real income (unless you think that fancy TV set or far away vacation is really important).

Fri Aug 01, 09:03:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

description of the data is wanting. Deflator is sequentially down from 2.6%? How exactly does that compute? Notwithstanding the esoteric debate about productivity and jobs, which itself is a manufactured number via the B/D adjustment. That said, 1.9% got us approx 448 last week and climbing on claims. So the notion that printing money and thwing it at consumers hoping to keep the velcoity of money psotive is a J O K E. Consumptrion like everything else in this country is overextended. Dismissing the deflator is the most absurd thing I have read. Where did you get your PHD?

Sun Aug 03, 10:27:00 PM EDT  
Blogger knzn said...

The deflator is down because the weak economy, and the need to spend more on imports, has reduced the demand for US products and prevented sellers from raising prices. (Ever heard of a demand curve?) That's how exactly it computes.

If the birth/death adjustment is becoming progressively too large, then productivity growth was even higher, since total hours worked (which derives from employment) is in the denominator of productivity.

As I said, 1.9% growth is probably not enough to maintain employment, but it's still more than I expected. With employment falling, it's not surprising to see initial unemployment claims rising, but my point is that the situation would be even worse if GDP were growing more slowly, as some deflator critics contend is true. (Also note that there is a temporary spike in initial claims due to the impact of the federal extended benefits program, which has made more people aware of their eligibility for state benefits.)

Sun Aug 03, 11:32:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Knzn,

My name is Vikram and I work for Wikinvest, an investing wiki with research about companies, concepts etc. I was wondering how I could get in touch with you regarding a product pitch that I think you'd be interested in. Visit my profile at http://www.wikinvest.com/user/Vikramparsani?profileType=public and send me an e-mail if you're interested.

Best Regards,

Vikram

Wed Aug 13, 04:35:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花東旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,租車公司,花蓮旅行社,花蓮旅遊景點,花蓮旅遊行程,花蓮旅遊地圖,花蓮一日遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車旅遊網,花蓮租車,花蓮租車,花蓮租車,花東旅遊景點,租車,花蓮旅遊,花東旅遊行程,花東旅遊地圖,花蓮租車公司,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊租車,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮賞鯨,花蓮旅遊,花蓮旅遊,租車,花蓮租車,花蓮租車 ,花蓮 租車,花蓮,花蓮旅遊網,花蓮租車網,花蓮,租車,花東 旅遊,花蓮 租車,花蓮,旅遊,租車公司,花蓮,花蓮旅遊,花東旅遊,花蓮地圖,包車,花蓮,旅遊租車,花蓮 租車,租車,花蓮租車資訊網,花蓮 旅遊,租車,花東,花東地圖,租車公司,租車網,花蓮租車旅遊,租車,花蓮,賞鯨,花蓮旅遊租車,花東旅遊,租車網,花蓮海洋公園,租車 ,花蓮 租車,花蓮,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車公司,租車花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮包車,花蓮租車網,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮旅行社,花東旅遊,花蓮包車,租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮一日遊,租車服務,花蓮租車公司,花蓮包車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮包車,花蓮租車網,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮租車,租車網,花蓮租車公司,花蓮旅遊,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,租車花蓮,租車服務,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮旅遊,花蓮賞鯨,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮包車,花蓮租車網,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,租車花蓮,花蓮租車網,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,租車花蓮,花蓮租車網,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮包車,花蓮,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮包車,花蓮租車網,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮包車,花蓮租車網,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮包車,花蓮租車網,租車公司,花蓮租車,花蓮租車公司,花蓮一日遊,花蓮旅遊,花蓮旅遊租車,花蓮租車網,花蓮租車,花蓮一日遊,租車花蓮,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊租車,花蓮租車,花蓮租車旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮旅遊,花蓮包車,花蓮溯溪,花蓮泛舟,花蓮溯溪旅遊網,花蓮旅遊,花蓮民宿,花蓮入口網,花蓮民宿黃頁,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,租車公司,花蓮旅遊租車,花蓮租車,租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花東旅遊,花蓮賞鯨,花蓮旅遊,花蓮泛舟,花蓮賞鯨,花蓮溯溪,花蓮泛舟,花蓮泛舟,花蓮溯溪,花蓮旅遊,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花東旅遊,花蓮,花東,花蓮旅遊,花東旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮,花東,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花東旅遊,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮,花東旅遊萬事通,花蓮旅遊,租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車,花蓮包車,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,花蓮租車旅遊網,花蓮太魯閣,花蓮旅遊網,花蓮包車,花東旅遊,花蓮旅遊行程,花蓮旅遊,花蓮 租車,花蓮租車資訊網,花蓮租車旅遊,花蓮旅遊租車,租車,花蓮旅遊推薦,花蓮旅遊包車,花蓮租車,花蓮,花蓮租車,花蓮地圖,花蓮旅遊優惠,花蓮旅遊資訊網,花蓮旅遊景點,賞鯨,花蓮行程,花蓮旅遊,花蓮旅遊租車,花東旅遊景點,花東旅遊行程,花蓮旅遊blog,花蓮旅遊,花蓮租車,租車,花東旅遊

Fri Apr 24, 04:13:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Modern tennis racquet in the manufacturing sector have been in use for close to the aerospace industry and military-industrial material products. Over the past two decades, metal materials and chemical materials to upgrade the high level of tennis racket manufacturer has laid a solid foundation. In today's big brands have more than tennis: Wilson tennis racquet,Head tennis racket,Babolat tennis racket,Head junior tennis racket,Wilson tennis racket......

Mon May 18, 11:37:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

1)
cheap hair straighteners
chi hair straightener
chi flat iron

new polo shirts
cheap Lacoste polo shirts
cheap Lacoste polo shirts

cheap handbags
cheap bags
puma chaussures
chaussures puma
chaussure puma

Men's North Face
Women's North Face


hair straighteners
sexy lingerie store
cheap ugg boots
tattoo wholesale
men's clothing
women's clothing


2009 nike shoes
new nike shoes
Women's max
Men's max 93
nike shox
Nike air force
Nike air max 2003
nike air max ltd
nike air max tn
Nike air rift
Nike air Yeezy
nike airmax
Nike air max 90
Nike air max 97
nike birds nest shoes
nike dunk
nike RT1 shoes
nike SB
nike shox shoes
Nike shox OZ shoes
Nike shox R2 shoes
Nike shox R3 shoes
Nike shox R4 shoes
Nike shox R5 shoes
Nike shox TL3
nike trainers lovers

tennis rackets
Wilson tennis rackets
HEAD tennis rackets
Babolat tennis rackets

Wed Jun 10, 01:18:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

designer sunglasses
Cheap shoes online
Wholesale Polo Shirts
Chaussures Sport
MBT shoes
cheap cell phones
sports shoes
nike tn air ma
clothes jeans
nike shoes

Mon Mar 29, 05:01:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

Coach handbags outlet,The relations between two elementsCheap Coach handbag, in the composition may be considered as two aspects – Discount Coach handbags,we are like fashion handbags and oter thingsDiscount Coach handbag,we have all kind od goods as you likeNewest Coach handbags musical instrument capable of establishing love it or you don't.LVBefore anotherexperts and designersDiscount LV Outletthey might be back in fashion again?Louis VuittonWhen my heart was hardened and my courses constrained Cheap Louis Vuitton Outletbut when I measured it by Your forgiveness Lord, newest Louis Vuitton 2010 It can be incredibly Its about materialism and can make you or break you. It means getting excited about Fall and Spring. Keep it in check or it love affair.cheap rain wearthey should be kept for the future. Who knows when discount rainwearthey should be kept for the future. Who knows when dog rain jacketsthey should be kept for the future. Who knows when colorful rain bootsi think fashion is something you wear obvouisly, or however that word is spelled Cheap Jeans outletthey should be kept for the future. Who knows when Diesel Jeansthey should be kept for the future. Levis Jeansthey should be kept for the future. Wholesale Ed Hardy Jeansthey should be kept for the future.Discount Jeans outletImagine this Certainly not!cheap abercrombie fitchthey should be kept for the future. Who knows when discount abercrombie & fitchthey should be kept for the future. discount abercrombie and fitchthey should be kept for the future. abercrombie fitch outletthey should be kept for the future. wholesale abercrombie fitchIn fact these days, clothes are stain-resistant and even waterproof.ed hardy wholesalecheap ed hardy wholesalethey should be kept for the future. discount ed hardy wholesalethey should be kept for the future. Who knows when wholesale ed hardythey should be kept for the future. Who knows when ed hardy outlet

Sun Apr 04, 08:28:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

Fashion trends change on daily basis, like Cheap GHD Straighteners (you can get it from a GHD Outlet), Why not get rid of your old straighteners to buy new GHDs? There is another kind hair straightener, called CHI hair Straighteners. Do you want to buy Discount GHD Styler? Following the latest in designer shades has become a passion of everyone, now 2010 Cheap Sunglasses, or we can say 2010 Discount Sunglasses. If you are the type of a woman who loves to explore in fashion, our Sunglasses Outlet will definitely satisfy your taste, because as you can see, we wholesale Sunglasses. Designer shades with optical grade lenses are important to protect our eyes from the sun. Don’t forget us-- Sunglasses Wholesale. Ed hardy streak of clothing is expanded into its wholesale ED Hardy chain so that a large number of fans and users can enjoy the cheap ED Hardy Clothes range easily with the help of numerous secured websites, actually, our discount ED Hardy Outlet. As we all know, in fact Wholesale Ed Hardy,is based on the creations of the world renowned tattoo artist Don Ed Hardy. Why Ed hardy wholesale? Well, this question is bound to strike the minds of all individuals. Many people may say cheap Prada is a joke, but we can give you discount Prada, because we have Prada Outlet. Almost everyone will agree that newest Prada handbags are some of the most beautiful designer handbags (Prada handbags 2010) marketed today. The reason is simple: fashion prohibited by AnkhRoyalty, in other words, we can write it as Ankh Royalty the Cultural Revolution. Straightens out the collar, the epaulette epaulet, the Ankh Royalty Clothing two-row buckle. Would you like to wear Ankh Royalty Clothes?Now welcome to our AnkhRoyalty Outlet. And these are different products that bear the most famous names in the world of fashion, like Ankh Royalty T-Shirt by the way -Prada, Spyder, Moncler, GHD, ED Hardy, designer Sunglasses, Ankh Royalty, Twisted Heart.

Sun Apr 04, 08:30:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

As responsible members of the global business community we have an obligation to ensure that our companies are run in a socially and ecologically responsible manner.MBT,MBT Shoes in fashion,Cheap MBT Shoes sale,Discount MBT outlet 2010,MBT Walking Shoes,Cheap Dior shoes,Discount Dior bags,Dior sunglasses,Dior outlet 2010,Newest Dior sunglasses.
On behalf of our customers and business partners, we actively support the International Labor Organization’s (ILO) effort to “promote social justice and internationally recognized human and labor rights.”Discount New Balance shoes,New Balance outlet,Cheap New Balance,New Balance running shoes,New Balance shoes 2010,Discount PUMA Outlet,Cheap PUMA,Puma 2010,Kids Puma Shoes,Puma Walking Shoes.

Sun Apr 04, 08:33:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

No matter what product you purchase from us north face jacketsWe are offering you a wide range ofnorth face outletquestion,Some color combinations seem to never get old north face outerwearBut within the same community north face coatsbecause it features just the right amount of north face uk

Mon Apr 19, 12:00:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

Teenagers in a track adidas tennis shoes can go through shoes rate discount

adidas sneakers
teenage runner well knows that newest adidas shoes 2010 to wear the right shoes discount moncler outlet any cross country among world cheap adidas shoes

especially important to the sportsman wholesale adidas shoes a young person growing up adidas shoes outlet Not only do they want to discount moncler t-shirt grow

out of their shoes cheap jordan shoes but shape of their feet changes new jordan shoes which means every time we new jordan

shoes
the time comes to get air jordan 2010 a new pair of shoes eveyone discount jordan shoes a good choice to get jumpman 23

it with a high material Jordan ajf shoes that breathes easily on random Newest Timberland shoes 2010 They should be extended runs cheap Nike shox shoes give enough

support to athlets discount brand shoes especially around the ankles area cheap Nike Dunk shoes to avoid injury your ankles AIR MAX shoes outlet when you make your

trip 2010 New GHD something in store possible fit Benefit GHD his is also the way to

Tue Apr 20, 01:32:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Frank said...

Hey,
Loving your blog, awesome tips on blog you have here. I
would just like to ask you some questions privately, mindIDM Free Download,function venues geelong,lifetime Fitness locations,Mobile Prices in Pakistan

Fri Sep 09, 07:19:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous jogos friv said...

Thanks for sharing this with us loved reading your article
----
i like play game jogos click online free and play game juegos de pou

Thu Aug 27, 02:52:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

I'm happy about everything you bring it very interesting and helpful, thanks
kids games online , friv 2 , jogos do friv , juegosjuegos.com , juegos de matar zombbies
, juegos de un show mas

Thu Sep 17, 05:37:00 AM EDT  
Blogger alicetaylor said...

This is a great article. It gave me a lot of useful information. thank you very much.
monkey go happy | monkey go happy 2 | learn to fly | learn to fly 3 | pacman | pacman game | mahjong | mahjong games | cat mario 4 | cat mario | happy wheels 2 | happy wheels

Tue Jan 12, 09:26:00 PM EST  
Blogger Regina Hilary said...

This app is great it gives you those moments of relaxation and incredibly wonderful
age of war 2 | tank trouble | gold miner | tank trouble 3
Just wanted to tell you keep up the fantastic work!my weblog:
earn to die 5 | earn to die 6

Wed Jun 22, 05:25:00 AM EDT  
Blogger yanmaneee said...

vapormax
golden gooses
nike shoes
cheap jordan shoes
adidas tubular
cheap jordans
adidas ultra boost
christian louboutin shoes
longchamp handbags
baseball jerseys

Mon Jul 15, 03:41:00 AM EDT  
Blogger infotech Zone 93 said...

Top Rated, Leading Finance Assessment Company in Eugeneinment in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon

CSK Dynamic Ventures LLC in Eugene, Oregon

Contact CSK Dynamic Ventures LLC in Eugene, Oregon

Business ventures in oregon

Finance Venture Company in oregon





Infotech Zone - Best Web Design, Best Web Development, Best Digital Marketing Company in Ludhiana, Punjab

Top Rated Best Graphic Designing, Best Web Design, Best Web Development and Best Digital Marketing Company in Ludhiana, Punjab

Top Rated SEO, SMO, Web Design and Digital Marketing Company in Ludhiana, PunjabInfotech Zone - Best Web Design, Best Web Development, Best Digital Marketing Company in Ludhiana, Punjab

Thu Jan 09, 05:27:00 AM EST  

Post a Comment

<< Home