Friday, March 30, 2012

Bullish It

OK, so I decided to do a substantive post – something I haven’t done in a while because this blog has fallen into the category where, if I have the time and energy to do this, then I also have the time and energy to do something more useful, so the only times I would be inclined to post are when I’m too busy or tired to do so. But OK, let’s say that this is useful sort of the way it was useful for my old roommate to fly back to England now and then so that he could maintain residency. After all, it seemed earlier today that Google might have revoked my visa. (For now I’ll table the question of whether the benefits of being a Blogger resident are comparable to those of being a UK resident.)

So, as the first word of the title suggests, I’m fairly optimistic about the US economy right now – where “optimistic” means I think there’s a genuine recovery going on and that it is likely to continue for at least several more months, not that I think things are going well in an absolute sense. (I mean, does anyone think things are going well in an absolute sense?) So I am more of a Smithian than a Smithist.

But another post to which I was referred by the Bearish Smith’s blog leads me to think about the issue of macroeconomics as a field. It seems (especially from the comment thread) that the Old Keynesians and the New Monetarists are at each other’s throats (but, interestingly, the newly christened Market Monetarists – who have some claim to being the legitimate intellectual heirs of the Old Monetarists – basically seem to be on the same side as the Old Keynesians on the major issues here; and the New Keynesians can break for either side depending on whether they’re more Keynesian or more New). Obviously I’m more sympathetic to the Old Keynesians than the New Monetarists, otherwise maybe my pseudonym would be “dsge” instead of “knzn.”

Here’s my take: to begin with, economics is basically bulls**t. I mean, it’s necessary bulls**t, sometimes even useful bulls**t, but I’m extremely skeptical of people who think economics is a science or that it could be a science. We have to make policy decisions (and investment decisions and personal consumption decisions etc.), and we have to have some basis for making them. We could just use intuition, and we often do, but it’s helpful to use logical thought and empirical data also, and systematic study using fields like economics can help us to clarify our intuition, our logical arguments, and our interpretation of the empirical data. The same way that bulls**t discussions that don’t make any pretense at being science can help.

Economics is bulls**t because it relies on the premise that human beings behave in a systematic way, and they don’t. Once you have done enough research to convince yourself that they behave in a certain way, they will change and start behaving in another way. Particularly if they read your research and realize that you’re trying to manipulate them by expecting them to continue behaving the way they have. But even if they don’t read your research, they may change the way they behave just because the zeitgeist changes – cultural sunspots, if you will.

The last paragraph may vaguely remind you of the Lucas critique. Lucas basically said that macroeconomics (as it was being practiced at the time) was bulls**t, but he held out the hope that it could receive micro-foundations that wouldn’t be bulls**t. The problem with Lucas’ argument, though, is that microeconomics is also bulls**t. And Noah Smith, writing some 36 years after the Lucas critique and observing its unwholesome results, takes it one step further by saying, if I may paraphrase, “Yes, the microeconomics upon which modern macro has now been founded is indeed bulls**t, but if we do the micro right, then we can come up with non-bulls**t macro.”

Yeah, I doubt it. Maybe we can come up with slightly better macro than what we’ve got now, but the underlying micro is never going to be right. Experimental results involving human subjects are inevitably subject to the micro version of the Lucas critique: once the results become well-known, they become part of a new environment that determines a new set of behavior. And the zeitgeist will screw with them also. And so on. And in any case, even if the results were robust, I’m skeptical that we can really build them into a macro model or that it would be worth the trouble even if we could. Economics will always be bulls**t.

Now there’s a case for doing rigorous bulls**t, at least as a potentially useful exercise. That’s what I think DSGE modeling is: it’s a potentially useful exercise in rigorous bulls**t. And I don’t begrudge the work of people like Steve Williamson: I think there's some rigorous bulls**t there that may be worth talking about. But in general, when it comes to bulls**t, there is not a monotonic relationship between rigor and usefulness. And to put all your eggs in the rigorous bulls**t basket – not only that, but in one particular type of rigorous bulls**t basket, because rigor does not live by rational equilibrium alone – is something that not even Pudd’nhead Wilson could advocate.

So I’m going to stick with sloppy Old Keynesian models as my main mode of macroeconomic analysis. They’re bulls**t. They’re not rigorous bulls**t. But as bulls**t goes, they’re pretty useful. A lot more useful than unaided intuition. And they’re easy enough to understand that we can have a reasonable idea of where their unrealistic assumptions are likely to lead us astray. Of course all economic models have unrealistic assumptions, but hopefully our intuition allows us to correct for that condition when applying the models to the real world. If the model is too complicated for the typical economist to understand how the assumptions generate the conclusions, then the unrealism becomes a real problem.

UPDATE: At the risk of making him guilty by association, I want to point to a post by Chris Dillow, where he makes a related point that is perhaps the point I would have tried to make if I had been in a less obnoxious mood.

UPDATE2: Noah Smith replies, defending economics as being (at least potentially) scientific. I'll concede that economics can have scientific elements (as, indeed, politics or warfare can have scientific elements), but I think those elements will always be relatively small and unimportant, whereas bulls**t will always be critical to the field.

153 Comments:

Anonymous marcel said...

1) Particularly if they read your research and realize that you’re trying to manipulate them by expecting them to continue behaving the way they have.

Dostoevski articulated this first (and in a more interesting way), certainly in "Notes from Underground" and likely (though I've forgotten lo, these many decades later) in the Bros. K.

2) You may need a new term, after Harry Frankfurt's treatise. It's clear, to me at least, that many macro types (e.g., Cochrane, Fama, Mankiw) treat macro as BS in just the way that Frankfort described BS, but I don't think that you mean it that way, and I think that, much like the recently established definition of "santorum" has become the dominant one in many people's minds, so has Frankfort's definition for BS.

Sat Mar 31, 08:33:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous nemi said...

Instan classic!

Sat Mar 31, 05:37:00 PM EDT  
Blogger TheCrisisStudent said...

"If the model is too complicated for the typical economist to understand how the assumptions generate the conclusions, then the unrealism becomes a real problem."

What a great sentence!!!

As a postgrad student, this corresponds to mine (and others') realization that my economic intuition got worse over the course of postgrad program...

Sun Apr 01, 05:30:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous hrsaccount said...

When I was in my 20's I interviewed two dozen successful business people from very different markets and varied backgrounds. Some had worked themselves up from extreme poverty, others born with the pulverable silver spoon.

I focused on how they made business decisions and surprisingly they all said the same thing; after reading business proposals and discussions with internal and external experts, the decision to go forward or pass....came down to a gut decision.

How would economist model a gut feeling?

Sun Apr 01, 07:24:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have been reading econ blogs for about a year now, and I must say that this is the most convincing piece I have read so far.

Economics sounds like religion, and economists like preachers debating their version of the dogma. After a very short while, the sensible person gets really turned off by all their ridiculous debates about the fine points for which they can bring zero evidence.

For an interesting book about the use of models, see "Science in the age of computer simulation" by Eric Winsberg.

Sun Apr 01, 12:26:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Alphonse said...

Amen. And you didn't even get around to "even if micro could be sound, what about emergent properties?"

Mon Apr 02, 12:23:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"All models are wrong, some are useful"
- George Box

When you refer to the fact modelling affects behaviour, you are referring to Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle. Before you go making generalizations about "economics vs science", you should make sure you have defined science at all, rather than making what might seem to be self evident assumptions about it.

I would reject the premise of this post simply because it seems to assume the problems inherent to economic modelling have been resolved in more readily quantifiable science; they most certainly have not. The innaccuracy of economic models might just seem more blatant because it affects us so directly.

How's that for problems with the "Zeitgeist," and proper analysis.

Fri Apr 06, 11:03:00 PM EDT  
Blogger knzn said...

In physics, Heisenberg's uncertainty principle is quantifiable and consistent. In economics, the processes we are studying take place in a time frame wider than the time frame in which intellectual progress takes place, so we can't quantify the ways in which that progress will fail.

Sat Apr 14, 09:02:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Make Your Fortune said...

Hello!
Join the largest system of making money and get $ 10 to test the system!
Visit us and attend conferences 24h/7days, get all your questions and see how everyone is happy!
No system is pyramid or multi-level and already has over 400,000 members!
We are waiting for you!

Sat Apr 14, 11:18:00 AM EDT  
Blogger noiln said...

Economics Development is a process whereby an economy’s real National Income Increases over a long period of time, and if the rate of development is greater than the rate of population growth, then pre capital real income will increase. Banks are the custodians and distributors of liquid capital which is the life blood of our commercial and industrial activities.

Sat Apr 28, 01:22:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous sewa mobil jakarta said...

Nice article, thanks for the information.

Wed May 02, 02:25:00 AM EDT  
Blogger jim john said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

Sat May 19, 02:00:00 PM EDT  
Blogger jim johnson said...

indeed. ;)

Sat May 19, 02:02:00 PM EDT  
Blogger noiln said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

Sat May 19, 02:04:00 PM EDT  
Blogger MrIlir said...

There is a new framework you may not think it's BS. Alex Gheg has a powerful and simple equation that does more than you might expect. Quantity, quality, variety and convenience all tied together. Imagine a scale that measure utility. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6tFLGpcOpE

Thu Sep 06, 09:17:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bridge

Sun Oct 28, 01:43:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous rental mobil bandung said...

very good article and useful, thank you for the information!

Tue Jan 21, 04:59:00 AM EST  
Anonymous Rental Mobil Bandung said...

Economy are important for every country.

Sun May 10, 11:36:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous facebook movil said...

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
----
five nights at freddy's demo | five nights at freddy's | fnaf 3

Fri May 22, 09:44:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Forte School Children classes said...

Funny word I picked up from blogging friends in far away places...Forte School Children classes I think this is the ideal post for me to express myself with that word!

Wed Jun 03, 11:09:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Chang bui thi said...

Great post. i like it. feeling great when reading your post .
i like play games friv online and play games2girls 2 online free and play game friv games and games 2 girls ! have fun!

Fri Jun 05, 05:30:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Whatsapp Descargar said...

Thanks for sharing. I hope it will be helpful for too many people that are searching for this topic.
Signature:
download free descargar whatsapp gratis and download baixar whatsapp gratis online and descargar whatsapp , baixar whatsapp

Wed Jun 10, 05:11:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous baixar facebook said...

I'm happy about everything you bring it very interesting and helpful, thanks
Signature:
Jugar juegos de frozen en línea gratis, los nuevos de princesa de Disney juegos frozen - la princesa encantadora y linda. Divertirse frozen!

Thu Jun 18, 10:02:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous furniture jepara said...



thanks to the info from my father added insight thank you so much, may be useful for us all
please aprove mister.
by sewa mobil semarang

Sun Aug 30, 01:10:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Juegos De Terror said...

run 3 game I read post... thanks u for sharing.
Thanks u so much.football heads
juegos de terror online
mahjong games
Cool math 4 kids

Wed Dec 02, 11:23:00 PM EST  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I focused on how they made business decisions and surprisingly they all said the same thing; after reading business proposals and discussions with internal and external experts, the decision to go forward or pass....came down to a gut decision. Lowongan Kerja SMA | Asik Itu Belajar

Mon Jan 04, 02:25:00 AM EST  
Blogger Riya Jacob said...

Such a nice post ! great love to read this one.

mumbai escorts
mumbai escorts
mumbai escorts
mumbai escorts
gurgaon escorts

Fri Feb 26, 09:30:00 AM EST  
Anonymous water heater said...

Very nice post. I simply stumbled upon your blog and wanted to mention that I’vereally loved surfing around your blog posts.
perdita di peso

Mon Mar 21, 07:52:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous cara menyembuhkan maag pada ibu hamil secara alami dan cepat said...

Thanks for sharing this post, very informative. I have really liked your writeup. Hope you will organize some giveaways on your blog as well.
cara menyembuhkan maag pada ibu hamil secara alami dan cepat
I really wana thank you for providing such informative and qualitative material so often. I just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. Keep up the great work, its hard to find good ones. I have added to my favorites. Thank You

Tue Mar 22, 09:37:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous obat susah buang air besar said...

Thanks for this great post, i find it very interesting and very well thought out and put together.
obat susah buang air besar / bab

Fri Mar 25, 10:06:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Dindin Island said...

Thank you for the article was very helpful, I liked his discussion and hopefully a lot of other people who may read this article Slimming Capsule

Thu Apr 14, 11:03:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Dindin Island said...

Thank you for the article was very helpful, I liked his discussion and hopefully a lot of other people who may read this article Pengobatan Sindrom Nefrotik Pada Anak

Tue Apr 19, 08:57:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Dindin Island said...

Thank you for the article was very helpful, I liked his discussion and hopefully a lot of other people who may read this article Obat Nyeri Sendi Terbaik

Thu Apr 21, 04:29:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Obat Nyeri Sendi Terbaik said...

Thank you for the article was very helpful, I liked his discussion and hopefully a lot of other people who may read this article Obat Nyeri Sendi

Mon May 09, 04:32:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Kidz said...

Science Kombat is a new browser-based game that lets some of history's most famous scientists duke it out in an epic grudge match. science kombat game
Open Facebook Account, How To Unlock Facebook Account Suddenly Locked.

Wed May 11, 04:15:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Rozersmith said...

Indeed i like your writing style..keep posting.http://awriter.org/We provide online essay writing service,do check our link.

Wed May 11, 06:31:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous obat maag saat puasa said...

You have raised an important issue..Thanks for sharing..I would like to read more current affairs from this blog..keep posting..
tips berpuasa sehat bagi penderita maag dan asam lambung
I’ve lately been looking for data roughly this topic for ages and yours is one of the finest I have found out so far. If accuracy be told how you’re no longer actually much more neatly-chosen than you might be right now.

Tue May 17, 04:46:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Harga Lecithin Softgel Green World said...

Harga Lecithin Softgel Green World

Sat May 21, 12:34:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous merokok dan kematian said...

Thank you for another essential article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a complete way of writing? I have a presentation incoming week, and I am on the lookout for such.

Mon May 23, 04:49:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous harga opc plus capsule said...

Benarkah Air Kelapa Muda Bermanfaat Bagi Penderita Batu Empedu ?
khasiat dan manfaat buah anggur untuk ibu hamil
manfaat buah anggur untuk kesehatan kulit

Mon Jun 13, 01:53:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Pengobatan Usus Lengket said...

Thank you for the article was very helpful, I liked his discussion and hopefully a lot of other people who may read this article. Obat Usus Lengket

Wed Jun 15, 10:41:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Yoko Hao said...

kickfit |
boxing | vo tu ve | kick boxing | Quyen Thai | muay thái | võ gậy arnis

Fri Jun 17, 12:02:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Regina Hilary said...

The war between humans, orcs and elves continues. Lead your race through a series of epic battles, using your crossbow to fend off foes and sending out units to destroy castles. Researching and upgrading wisely will be crucial to your success!
slitherio | unfair mario 2 | age of war 2
The game controls are shown just under . Movement mechanisms primarily include acceleration and tilting controls.
cubefield | tank trouble | happy wheels | earn to die 2 |earn to die 6

Tue Jun 28, 09:46:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Yoko Hao said...

yêu | tình yêu | ba bau | bà bầu | mang xa hoi | bao mang | bao 24h |

Sun Jul 17, 08:01:00 PM EDT  
Blogger xjd7410@gmail.com said...

nike nfl jerseys
fitflops
michael kors handbags
toms shoes
nike air max
michael kors outlet online
tiffany outlet
adidas ultra boost
vans shoes
christian louboutin sale
christian louboutin outlet
nike uk
louis vuitton outlet
coach factory outlet
nike air max
coach factory outlet
adidas yeezy
christian louboutin
kobe shoes 11
coach outlet store online
louis vuitton outlet
ralph lauren outlet
replica watches
oakley sunglasses
jordan retro 3
ray bans
jordan shoes
timberland boots
ralph lauren polo
michael kors handbags
ray ban sunglasses
coach outlet
cheap jordans
lebron james shoes
jeremy scott shoes
ray ban sunglasses
toms
coach outlet store online
michael kors handbags
ed hardy clothing
2016.7.18haungqin

Sun Jul 17, 09:49:00 PM EDT  
Blogger chenlina said...

chenlina20160719
jordans for sale
toms outlet
jordan concords
coach outlet
nike air jordan
louis vuitton handbags
toms shoes outlet online
kevin durant shoes 7
michael kors outlet
adidas nmd
coach outlet store online
louboutin shoes
kids lebron shoes
kate spade handbags
gucci outlet
louis vuitton outlet stores
coach outlet
coach outlet store online
nike outlet store
fitflops shoes
coach outlet
louboutin pas cher
nike air force 1
michael kors handbags
cheap oakley sunglasses
hollister clothing
marc jacobs handbags
coach outlet store online
rolex watches
louis vuitton handbags
oakley sunglasses
jordan 4
oakley sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
louis vuitton outlet
louis vuitton purses
adidas shoes
michael kors outlet
air jordans
burberry outlet
as

Tue Jul 19, 02:23:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous catering makassar said...

rantang murah makassar
catering prasmanan makassar
rantang kantoran makassar
nasi dos makassar

Sat Jul 23, 08:15:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous catering makassar said...

rantang murah makassar
catering prasmanan makassar
rantang kantoran makassar
nasi dos makassar

Sat Jul 23, 08:16:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous toyota makassar said...

toyota makassar
promo toyota makassar
dealer toyota makassar
toyota calya makassar
toyota sienta makassar

Sat Jul 23, 08:18:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous rental mobil makassar said...

rental mobil makassar
sewa mobil makassar
rental bus makassar
rental elf makassar

Sat Jul 23, 08:20:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous daihatsu makassar said...

daihatsu makassar
daihatsu sigra makassar

Sat Jul 23, 08:22:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous lecithin softgel said...

Lecithin Softgel Green World
Harga Dan Cara Pemesanan Lecithin Softgel Green World

Thu Jul 28, 02:02:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Huyền Ngọc said...

Video sản phẩm máy đóng gói
Máy đóng đai thùng
Máy dán thùng carton

Sat Aug 06, 12:28:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Giải Trí Tổng Hợp said...

Welcomes to google terminal keep sharing such ideas in the future as well.
google snake this was actually EARN TO DIE
what i was looking for,and i am glad to came here! AGE OF WAR 2
Hi! I’ve been reading your blog for a while HAPPY WHEELS
I want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read!!! Slitherio
Amazing insight you have on this, Slither io This article always blew me BIG FARM
hotmail sign in | hotmail login
sign in to hotmail | log in to hotmail

Sun Aug 07, 09:52:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Team NCT said...

In lịch nẹp thiếc 5 tờ
Báo giá in lịch tết
In lịch để bàn giá rẻ
Báo giá in lịch tết 2017
Dầu gội GATASE
Phục hồi tóc cháy
Phục hồi tóc tại nhà
Phục hồi tóc yếu
Phục hồi tóc chẻ ngọn
Phục hồi tóc nát
Máy ép cám viên
Máy đùn cám viên
Máy băm nghiền đa năng
Máy nghiền vỡ hạt ngô
Máy thái rau
Van uống nước cho thỏ
Tấm nhựa đa năng
Lồng công nghiệp
Tam nhua da nang
Máy thái cây chuối
Mang an cho tho
Van uong nuoc cho tho
May dun cam vien
Máy thái cỏ
Máy nghiền thức ăn
Máy đùn cám viên
Video máy ép cám viên
Video hướng dẫn làm cám cho thỏ
Máy ép cám viên kiểu đứng

Sun Aug 14, 12:54:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Team NCT said...

Tỏi đen học viện quân y
Trà giảm cân học viện quân y
In thẻ nhựa
In lịch tết
In lịch tết 2017
Phục hồi tóc hư tổn
Máy làm cám
Máy ép cám viên
Cách sử dụng tỏi đen
Tác dụng của tỏi đen
in thẻ bảo hành
In thẻ học sinh, sinh viên
In thẻ gửi xe, vé xe
In thẻ VIP
Phôi thẻ nhựa
In lịch để bàn
In lịch để bàn chữ A
In lịch để bàn chữ M
In lịch lò xo 7 tờ
In lịch nẹp thiếc 1 tờ

Sun Aug 14, 12:54:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Tran Hien said...

Introducing to you some of the current hot game
red ball 3 || age of war
or
tank trouble || happy wheels
or
earn to die
this is one of the cult game now, a lot of people enjoy playing them :
slitherio || wingsio
Welcome to the website which is dedicated to the most funny and addicting
unblocked game| mills eagles | kids games |
action games | flash games | stickman games
gmail sing in

Thu Aug 25, 04:38:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Anita Romanenko said...

college application essay writing service Excellent post.I want to thank you for this informative read, I really appreciate sharing this great post. Keep up your work. 

Wed Sep 07, 06:08:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Rental Mobil Bandung said...

keren mang

Wed Sep 07, 11:38:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Much obliged such a great amount for this data. I need to tell you I agree on a few of the focuses you make here and others may require some further audit, however I can see your perspective. Ini Dia Cara Mengobati Batu Empedu Dengan Kelapa Hijau

Thu Sep 08, 02:03:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous quà tặng doanh nghiệp said...

Công ty quà tặng GIGA

Tue Sep 13, 12:06:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Kiên Văn Đình said...

The blog or and best that is extremely useful to keep I can share the ideas. Age Of War 2
Big Farm | Slitherio | Tank Trouble
Of the future as this is really what I was looking for, I am very comfortable and pleased to come here. Thank you very much.
Happy Wheels | Goodgeme Empire | Slither.io

Fri Sep 30, 10:30:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Mhas Allians said...

obat angin duduk di apotik penyebab telat haid tukang behel gigi jakarta

Sat Dec 24, 01:53:00 AM EST  
Blogger Freddie King said...

Thank you for taking the time and sharing this information with us. It was indeed very helpful and insightful while being straight forward and to the point.
www.McdonaldsGutscheine.net | Startlr

Wed May 17, 01:47:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Obat Asam Lambung said...

Obat Asam Lambung
Agen Agaricpro denpasar
Agen Agaricpro Jakarta
Agen Agaricpro Tangerang
Agen Agaricpro Makasar
Agen Agaricpro Banjarmasin
Agen Agaricpro Medan
Agen Agaricpro Palembang

Mon May 22, 02:25:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Obat Servitis Kronis said...

Obat Servisitis Kronis

Tue May 23, 02:36:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Cara Alami Menghilangkan Keloid Bekas Operasi Caesar said...

Cara Alami Menghilangkan keloid bekas operasi caesar

https://goo.gl/tpHhg6

Wed May 31, 09:47:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Leti Latifah said...

I really hope the admin of posting his latest article, which is definitely more interesting and useful. Waiting for a visit back to my blog, Thank you.

Solusi Terbaik Atasi Miom Tanpa Operasi

Sun Jun 04, 09:47:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Visit W3Schools

Wed Jun 07, 09:10:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Idoy Dunia Terbalik said...

Info Obat Luka Borok Reaksi Cepat Paling Ampuh 100% Herbal. Kunjungi Blognya http://goo.gl/iDpg8g

Wed Jun 07, 11:37:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Jelly Gamat Jakarta said...

Jelly Gamat Jakarta

Jelly Gamat Kuningan

Jelly Gamat Bandung 

Jelly Gamat Bali

Cara Mengobati Gangguan Tidur

Obat Sirup Penurun Panas Anak

Cara Mencegah Pusing Saat Hamil

Jelly Gamat Jakarta Pusat

Agen Jelly Gamat Jakarta

Jelly Gamat Sirup

Thu Jun 22, 12:31:00 AM EDT  
Blogger شركة قمة الدقة said...

شركة تنظيف منازل بالدمام
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالجبيل

Wed Jul 05, 11:58:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Mehndi Designs all said...

Rosemary helps to unclog the strands of hair mehndi designs and hence promotes hair regrowth. This is for sale in the involving oils for you to massage on your scalp; you'll find it has anti-oxidants properties.

Mon Jul 10, 11:59:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Mehndi Designs all said...

For conditioning purposes why not look in mehndi designs a very leave on conditioner? Even adding herbal treatments may well your hair feel silkier.

Tue Jul 11, 06:23:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Thoughts said...

Could possibly experience that sick on the pit thought for the day of one's stomach feeling, physical symptoms such as sweaty palms or a desire to Fuggedabout Everything And Run (F.E.A.R.).

Sat Jul 15, 10:08:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Remove shortcut virus said...

search engine to determine whether remove shortcut virus other people have received this is equally note. A security site may already pegged it as a shortcut virus remover hoax.

Tue Jul 18, 06:19:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am a fantastic manager but i am not able to set different lineups for batting first and batting second. Please help me.
cara pemesanan qnc jelly gamat via sms

Thu Aug 17, 10:25:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous Cara Menyembuhkan Penyakit Kulit Herpes Secara Alami said...

Thank you for the information, hopefully the better the day his work

http://mysifasta.blogspot.co.id/2017/09/cara-menyembuhkan-penyakit-kulit-herpes.html

Mon Sep 18, 03:03:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I truly enjoyed the quality information you provide for your site visitors? Is going to be back again soon to check out new posts manfaat dan cara mengolah duan seledri sebagai Obat batu ginjal

Tue Nov 07, 02:08:00 AM EST  
Blogger herbal afgaricpro said...

very helpful and add new knowledge, quite easy to understand, I am waiting for the next article Cara Ampuh Mengobati Asam LambungCara Mengobati Hernia Tanpa Operasi, Obat Asam UratHerbal Agaricpro

Sun Nov 12, 09:03:00 PM EST  
Blogger Shyaam said...

A frantic note within the friend saying they've been infected, thereby so an individual have. This is likely a joke. shortcut virus remover

Tue Nov 14, 12:32:00 AM EST  
Blogger Thoughts said...

You then become a well-rounded individual because try to adapt to the personalities that surround you thought of the day.

Wed Nov 15, 02:04:00 AM EST  
Blogger Le Nguyen said...

Mẫu móc khóa đẹp giá rẻ

Thu Nov 16, 09:37:00 PM EST  
Blogger Umar said...

Ensure that a person the security and bug updates for your subscription duration SAP fiori.

Sat Nov 25, 12:47:00 AM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...

Thank you for the information...
Pantangan Makanan Bagi Penderita Penyakit Jantung

Cara Mengatasi Lambung Perih

Wed Nov 29, 08:44:00 PM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...

obat herbal gendang telinga pecah
Ramuan Untuk infeksi Saluran kemih (ISK)
Ramuan herbal untuk penyakit lupus
Cara Mengatasi Sinusitis Akut

Wed Nov 29, 10:04:00 PM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...

Cara Menghilangkan Miom Di Rahim
Pengobatan Herbal Diabetes Melitus Tipe 1 dan 2
Obat Radang panggul Di Apotik
ramuan herbal untuk penyakit asma

Wed Nov 29, 10:08:00 PM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...

pengobatan sinusitis di rumah

Wed Nov 29, 10:24:00 PM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...


Thank you for the information...
Cara Mengobati Polip Hidung Tanpa Operasi

Wed Nov 29, 10:39:00 PM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...

Thank you for the information..
Cara Mengobati kaku Persendian

Tue Dec 12, 01:53:00 AM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...


Thank you for the information..
Cara Mengobati kaku Persendian
Obat Penyakit Ginjal Bocor Pada Anak dan Dewasa
Obat Congek Telinga Berair Pada Anak
Tips Menanggani Sinusitis Di Rumah
Cara Menghilangkan Asma Secara Permanen
Cara Mengobati Polip Hidung Tanpa Operasi
Pantangan Makanan Bagi Penderita Penyakit Jantung

Tue Dec 12, 01:56:00 AM EST  
Blogger Sinuses said...

It additionally important find out that a lot of can stay cold just for a long cycle. In some of quite big games a precise number might not see the lighting of day in many, many quarters visit this blog.

Tue Dec 12, 08:56:00 AM EST  
Blogger Z4root said...

We use numbers completed as we shop, play games, discuss times and dates, and interact in the same room. In order to potential to function in 2nd language, it's to master using phone numbers original blog.

Tue Dec 12, 11:33:00 PM EST  
Blogger Remove Shortcut said...

Avoid the double combos as well as the triple permutations. And start playing the single combos the only one. You will greatly improve your pick 3 lottery improvement source here.

Thu Dec 14, 02:37:00 AM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...

Thank you for the information..
Cara Mengatasi Kadar Bilirubin Tinggi , Obat Hernia Tanpa Operasi Anak Bayi Dewasa 100% Alami

Thu Dec 14, 09:31:00 PM EST  
Blogger sandi mulyana said...

very helpful and add new knowledge, quite easy to understand, I am waiting for the next article Cara Mengobati Hernia pada Bayi, Balita dan Anak Tanpa Operasi, Cara Mengobati Ginjal Bocor, cara mengatasi asam lambung kambuh

Thu Dec 14, 09:37:00 PM EST  
Blogger thought said...

Another important distinction of guitars is that some have a hollow body and some have powerful body. Each variety of body delivers individual unique sound click this text.

Thu Dec 14, 11:25:00 PM EST  
Blogger Robert Merck said...

Calories from fat experience you gain, exterior lights money discover win. Each new item, including crops, animals and trees produce more cash for you as you play video game more explanation here.

Fri Dec 15, 12:14:00 AM EST  
Blogger Arf player said...

The reality, though, is that tight players do tend to play the hands they do vacation in aggressively. Possess to, that they want products and are the most of each situation click here
.

Fri Dec 15, 11:44:00 PM EST  
Blogger Wudu said...

Of course nylon strings will not give you an identical sound effect as their steel counterparts but they will give merely peculiar sound that will touch your soul. Whenever you play completely always a great feeling visit author.

Wed Dec 20, 02:02:00 AM EST  
Blogger Gdnt Msgs said...

Of course, it can be performed to find matching cards in the flop, ladies often really can simply loose money. If you found a satisfactory hand, listen to it tight and fold the opposite ones check our site.

Wed Dec 20, 11:40:00 PM EST  
Blogger Online Apps said...

We can all create teamy groups of skilled players who what to see happy one a second! It's not just important every player's individual success, however for our team's corporate success as perfectly click here to open.

Thu Dec 21, 10:27:00 PM EST  
Blogger Sinuses said...

Washington is coming off an excessive win against last year's NFC Champion Eagles which moved them into 2nd place inside the division at the side of idle Dallas, tx come again.

Fri Dec 22, 11:26:00 PM EST  
Blogger Z4root said...

Consumers can anticipate a payment of $150 for your product. Infinitec will release the product sometime come july 1st. Make sure to keep your attention out for this awesome product or services why dont check this.

Sat Dec 23, 10:24:00 PM EST  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.
Walatra sehat wasir obat wasir terbaik
manfaat daun wungu sebagai Obat wasir
obat wasir terbaik tanpa operasi
Kandungan dan manfaat daun wungu

Sun Dec 24, 08:07:00 PM EST  
Blogger Sinuses said...

Watch them carefully for several minutes areas to take more will help you make sick author's bio.

Thu Jan 04, 11:30:00 PM EST  
Blogger Andhra Member said...

Byron Leftwich continues to play correctly. He directed two scoring drives of 80+ yards in the fourth quarter last month to beat Houston visit this link.

Fri Jan 05, 07:22:00 AM EST  
Blogger andhra students said...

The biggest choice in order to create as you enter the regarding gaming is: computer or console? Some consoles own the rights to certain titles check me.

Fri Jan 05, 10:00:00 PM EST  
Blogger JNTU All 30 said...

Be sure the games do require hours to play, like monopoly. There of that game, try setting up different games at each table. Have a Connect Four Table, a Checkers table, and so forth why dont you try.

Sun Jan 07, 12:51:00 AM EST  
Blogger Sinus Old said...

With the confidence gained from reading this article, discover that the ready to partake in the ranks of gamers everywhere. Most desirable of luck to shoppers got here!

Sun Jan 07, 02:03:00 AM EST  
Blogger Remove Shortcut said...

In the NBA, means positivity . hold a mid to late first round pick you hope that your scouting is actually up to par click here.

Sun Jan 07, 10:11:00 PM EST  
Blogger thought said...

The packing of Sony DPF-D720 can be very delicate. Sleeping mode . the striking appearance besides other features. The packing saving is also in line with environmentally friendly theme help us here.

Mon Jan 08, 10:14:00 PM EST  
Blogger Robert Merck said...

Using a drum, totally . find 55 and another drum is made up of 42 red balls and also the red and white balls are consumed in it click to url.

Tue Jan 09, 10:24:00 PM EST  
Blogger Abortion said...

Help each other past hindrances. To me, this is on the list of greatest reasons for being on the team. You're never the only person try this.

Wed Jan 10, 10:41:00 PM EST  
Blogger lenguyen said...

Jacogroup chuyên sản xuất và cung cấp các sản phẩm quà tặng doanh nghiệp độc đáo chất lượng

Mon Jan 15, 02:38:00 AM EST  
Blogger Wudu said...

The 3.3-inch screen displays a bright and vivid release. Its 5mp camera captures 720p video, and playback of videos fantastic for click this.

Tue Jan 16, 10:22:00 AM EST  
Blogger Gdnt Msgs said...

Around two-thirds most winning numbers have been losing numbers for nine game or less. Those losing numbers that tend to be out for twelve games or less will be represented in the winning selection about seventy-five per cent of the time. this blog

Wed Jan 17, 06:49:00 AM EST  
Blogger Online Apps said...

Back in 2006, there seemed to be a different supporting player improving each title. James Posey one game. Antoine Walker another. Even Jason Williams got in on the action.answers

Wed Jan 17, 11:10:00 PM EST  
Blogger Sinuses said...

In the NBA, have got hold a mid to late first round pick you hope that your scouting will be up to par. try here

Thu Jan 18, 10:12:00 PM EST  
Blogger Z4root said...

The club must be held lightly, as if holding a wide open tube of toothpaste that's not a problem cap erased. This is a very difficult right move because it is a person's instinct to secure the shaft as tightly and swing as hard while you possibly visit this

Sat Jan 20, 01:28:00 AM EST  
Blogger Remove Shortcut said...

Even though Ripken retired in 2001 and was inducted in the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2007, Cal has not yet been faraway from baseball. click here

Sat Jan 20, 11:30:00 PM EST  
Blogger Robert Merck said...

There are two menus in digital frame. One is the view mode setting and the opposite one is the basic information and special function laying down. visit this url

Mon Jan 22, 12:05:00 AM EST  
Blogger Arf player said...

With Samsung's unique inbox feature, seeing all emails in a single place s extremely impressive and uncomplicated. visit this link

Mon Jan 22, 11:29:00 PM EST  
Blogger Abortion said...

Morris very well be able to spell minutes for Paul Pierce and Kevin Garnett, and teamed with Rondo and Jeff Green, he'd give the celtics a young athletic lineup, that vital in the NBA at present.click here for forum

Tue Jan 23, 10:20:00 PM EST  
Blogger Wudu said...

A player that the celtics hope to be presented with the 25th pick is power foward Markieff Morris off the University of Kansas. Slated to track his twin brother Marcus, Markieff has quietly upped his draft stock.
check bio

Wed Jan 24, 10:20:00 PM EST  
Blogger Gdnt Msgs said...

Since we have been spared to date from any major storms or power outages (knock on wood), we haven't used that old generator I keep in the spare room.
try here

Fri Jan 26, 10:02:00 PM EST  
Blogger Online Apps said...

According to Samsung, bada could be the easy to use type of OS, which will combine the greatness of having rich 3rd-party apps with an user-friendly interface that will appeal to every average person out there. visit this blog

Sat Jan 27, 10:22:00 PM EST  
Blogger Zindexer said...

All I'm trying to do is hit it on the fairway." They'll likely proceed to try to steer the ball for the middle. They take it halfway back and halfway through. click to check

Sun Jan 28, 09:55:00 PM EST  
Blogger Z4root said...

Its 5mp camera captures 720p video, and playback of videos is great. Watching myself stream an episode of work from my computer to my tv set was impressive. click this link

Wed Jan 31, 06:39:00 AM EST  
Blogger Remove Shortcut said...

Believe me, you need to want our nation's dependable FDA overlooking a buyer's general overall healthiness. Nobody likes to receive worthless salt tablets being shipped from Hong Kong. click to get

Sat Feb 03, 12:47:00 AM EST  
Blogger thought said...

The Atlanta Falcons traded a Never. 2 pick in this year's NFL Draft on Friday to the Kansas City Chiefs for 10-time Pro Bowl tight end Tony Gonzalez. try this link

Sun Feb 04, 10:09:00 PM EST  
Blogger Arf player said...

Remember though - simply creating finances isn't ample. In fact, developing a budget is particularly easy. Adhering to it and achieving the discipline to be firm with yourself, may be the difficult . authors bio

Mon Feb 05, 10:52:00 PM EST  
Blogger Sinuses said...

Trade down: If they do not like price comes from that is on the board when their name is called, visit this link

Thu Feb 15, 06:25:00 AM EST  
Blogger Z4root said...

Straightforward - we have a technique of fighting as well as locking up these violent thugs - just carried out already!Cystic acne is really a severe form of acne vulgaris and yes it takes time to cure it. This associated with acne occurs deep into the skin when the oil glands get blocked and inflamed. check it here

Fri Feb 16, 10:20:00 PM EST  
Blogger Sinuses said...

every political party and every religion doing work for the well-being and freedom of absolutely everyone of America who are here rightfully.
visit this

Tue Feb 27, 11:07:00 PM EST  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I consider this post as one of the best post ever. It is one of a kind. I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs. Your such a lucky one to have this gift basket of knowledge. Keep it up !
Ciri dan gejala penyakit difteri pada anak
Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing ...

Sat Mar 03, 02:56:00 AM EST  
Blogger Le Nguyen said...

Jacogroup chuyên sản xuất và cung cấp các sản phẩm quạt nhựa quảng cáo chất lượng

Sun Mar 04, 09:05:00 PM EST  
Blogger Online Apps said...

ABC's daytime department president Brian Frons said Thursday that "viewers are trying to find different varieties of programming these days." Holy Susan Lucci.say it isn't so.
check it here

Mon Mar 05, 02:06:00 AM EST  
Blogger Z4root said...

Many believe this is barely a reprieve and that God should be simply giving us another chance and what we use it will determine how we grow and prosper visit here

Mon Mar 05, 11:49:00 PM EST  
Blogger JNTU All 30 said...

However, it is a secure oral medication which in order to be taken with strict supervision by tips due to the side-effects. visit this url

Sun Mar 18, 12:57:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Tinah sutinah said...

I am very happy to find this information and I think this is a good blog that provides useful information. https://www.reflector-online.com/users/profile/qncjellygamat/

Mon Apr 09, 12:03:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Quà tặng doanh nghiệp said...

Mẫu móc khóa giá rẻ

Thu Apr 12, 10:10:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Raya Resmana said...

very interesting information, I really like it because it can add insight for me more broadly, thank you very much for this extraordinary information
Cara Mengempeskan Prostat Bengkak

Tue Apr 17, 03:30:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Le Nguyen said...

Jacogroup chuyên sản xuất và cung cấp các sản phẩm quạt nhựa chất lượng

Wed Apr 18, 03:49:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Batdongsansungroup.com.vn said...

https://batdongsansungroup.com.vn/premier-village-phu-quoc-resort/premier-village-phu-quoc-resort-176

Thu Jun 07, 02:49:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Unknown said...

Artikel yang sangat menarik dan sangat bermanfaat. Semoga bisa
Nutrinext Kapsul
Nutrinext Kapsul

Tue Jun 12, 11:50:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous obat stroke said...

Thanks for sharing. I hope it will be helpful for too many people that are searching for this topic,, your article is the best, keep up the good work..

Best Regard : http://www.nutrinextherbal.com/, http://www.goldengamat.co.id/, https://www.dalimogold.co.id/, http://billygandara.com/, http://sadayaherbal.com/

- http://www.nutrinextherbal.com/
- http://www.goldengamat.co.id/
- https://www.dalimogold.co.id/
- http://billygandara.com/
- http://sadayaherbal.com/

Tue Jun 12, 01:55:00 PM EDT  
Blogger Batdongsansungroup.com.vn said...

Thông tin chi tiết về dự án shophouse địa trung hải

Wed Jun 13, 11:17:00 PM EDT  
Anonymous nutrinext said...

Thanks,, your article is the best.



Best Regard : http://www.nutrinextherbal.com/,
http://www.goldengamat.co.id/,
https://www.dalimogold.co.id/

,
https://hexabumin.com/





- http://www.nutrinextherbal.com/

- http://www.goldengamat.co.id/

- https://www.dalimogold.co.id/

Fri Jun 29, 04:13:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Ini Herbal said...


Obat Batuk Alergi
Cara Menghentikan Darah Istihadhah
Obat Resdung

Fri Jul 20, 03:19:00 AM EDT  
Blogger obi duatilu said...

very interesting information, I really like it because it can add insight for me more broadly, thank you very much for this extraordinary information
obat herbal benjolan di jempol kaki akibat asam urat, obat luka jatuh herbal agar cepat kering tanpa membekas,

Tue Jul 24, 04:46:00 AM EDT  
Blogger Yaro Gabriel said...

www0728

jordans
ralph lauren uk
canada goose outlet
kate spade outlet online
cheap snapbacks
canada goose outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
coach outlet online
true religion outlet
ugg boots clearance







Sat Jul 28, 02:54:00 AM EDT  
Anonymous Obat Mata Juling said...

His article is very helpful at all thanks

Obat Penyakit Asam Urat
Obat Kanker Rahim
Obat Gatal Berair di Ketiak
Cara Mengobati Sakit Pinggang
Cara Mengobati Benjolan Di Vagina
Pengobatan Alami Penyakit vertigo

Sat Aug 04, 10:32:00 PM EDT  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home