Sunday, January 11, 2009

Rational Policy

Why is it that so many economists assume that private agents are rational but policymakers are irrational?

Breaking with that rather silly custom, Nick Rowe (hat tip: Mark Thoma) applies the rational expectations concept to policymakers and reaches the conclusion that we will never be able to find evidence of policy effectiveness, even if policies are actually quite effective.

One way to think about it, perhaps, is that all we observe in the data are the effects of policy mistakes. We cannot observe policy successes because they are negative events -- non-recession, non-inflation, etc. Only if policymakers were irrational would their "successes" -- the success of perverse policies at producing perverse effects -- correspond to positive events like recessions and inflation, so that we could find correlations between policy measures and outcomes.

To be more precise, any unusual events (recessions, inflations, etc.) that we see in the data must have been unpredictable; otherwise policymakers would have predicted and avoided them. But if they were unpredictable, that means they couldn't have been correlated with any variable that is supposed to measure policy; otherwise policymakers could have observed that variable and predicted and avoided the unusual event.

I made a similar point a couple of years ago: the inability of economists to forecast recessions is actually a point in favor of the economics profession, because it means that economists who guide public policy are doing their job well and avoiding all the predictable recessions.

21 comments:

  1. I like the point you made in 2007. Yes, it's directly related. Nothing targeted should be forecastable at or beyond the targeting horizon.

    Trying to get around the problem, I did a paper with Gabriel Rodriguez showing that US money does not cause US output, but does cause Hong Kong output (US Fed does not target Hong Kong output, but linked via fixed exchange rates).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the first Bush recession was predicable because of the role of Y2K remediation in corporate spending. I also think Y2K contributed to the following "jobless" recovery. Those were high paying jobs that went poof forever on the magic midnight. This makes the nature of those lost jobs different than jobs lost to a recession, no recovery was going to require those jobs be filled again.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Modern tennis racquet in the manufacturing sector have been in use for close to the aerospace industry and military-industrial material products. Over the past two decades, metal materials and chemical materials to upgrade the high level of tennis racket manufacturer has laid a solid foundation. In today's big brands have more than tennis: Wilson tennis racquet,Head tennis racket,Babolat tennis racket,Head junior tennis racket,Wilson tennis racket......

    ReplyDelete
  4. 故人のお部屋に残された様々な遺品整理。神奈川の住宅,一戸建て, 千葉 不動産なら神奈川県の不動産会社シティネット。不動産 東京はお任せ下さい!しゃぶしゃぶ(小尾羊)は全世界で700店以上を展開。世界中で愛される本格薬膳蒙古火鍋食べ放題 銀座しゃぶしゃぶの専門店です。
    ベネフィットライフなら首都圏の不動産仲介手数料が最大無料でお得!横浜市港北区 不動産,神奈川の住宅,一戸建て, 川崎 不動産,川崎市高津区 不動産,旭区,金沢区,港南区,南区,磯子区,中区など、横浜の仲介物件, ほとんどの新築一戸建てが仲介手数料0円!仲介手数料無料 未公開物件!仲介手数料不要で不動産購入可能!水道救急車はご家庭の水漏れ修理、トイレ詰まり(つまり)、水道 工事
    などにすぐ出動します。自分では治せない、蛇口、トイレの水漏れ修理や水回りの取り換え、リフォームや、ビル、マンションなどの改修工事までのお困りの方は即対応の「水道救急車」にお任せ下さい。

    ReplyDelete
  5. China Wholesale is very popular in recent years and we are professional china

    wholesaler and we provide you Cheap

    Wedding Dresses
    as well as cheap

    cocktail dresses
    with top quality and cheapest prices.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Dang it looks like the following week-end is out too!!! But I am back on that Monday and there will be a cake!
    That one was dropped on me from above.
    It appears that enjoyable distance typing it is, at least for now. That Monday? July/August?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Pls cut out the crap.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I like your article, really interesting! My point is also very good, I hope you'll like:chi flat iron are a very popular choice of hair straightener.New Balance,new Blance shoes,new Blance Outlet are some of the most comfortable and stylish shoes on the market today. The designer has a whole range of shoes for all types of athletes. five finger shoes,vibram five fingers,Five fingers shoes give women the feeling of walking barefoot while still keeping the feet protected.

    ReplyDelete
  9. 輕輕的裝潢|我走了,正如我輕輕的來;
    我輕輕的植牙。 招手,作別西天的雲彩。

    那河畔的室內設計金柳,是夕陽中的新娘;

    波光裡的貨運艷影,在我的心頭蕩漾。

    軟泥留學上的青荇,油油的在水底招搖;
    在康河隔熱紙的柔波里,我甘心做一條水草!

    那榆蔭下的婚禮顧問一潭,不是清泉,
    是天上虹揉碎在浮藻間,沉澱著彩虹似的夢。

    尋夢? 撐一支長篙,向青草更青處漫溯,
    滿載一船星輝,在星輝減肥斑斕裡放歌。

    但我夏令營不能放歌,悄悄是別離的笙簫;
    夏蟲也為我沉默,沉默是今晚的康橋。
    夏令營

    ReplyDelete
  10. The blog or and best that is extremely useful to keep I can share the ideas superslot

    ReplyDelete